Tonight’s story may be a familiar tale to many of you. That’s because I’ve talked extensively about Inō Mononoke Roku in the past on this blog. I even did an entire A-Yokai-A-Day on this amazing legend several years back, which are viewable in the archives.

That this story reached Negishi on Sado Island (or perhaps Edo, if he was there at the time) is a testament to how popular and widespread this legend was. It was truly known all over Japan. It’s also interesting, because Inō Mononoke Roku is generally known to have some elements of truth to it — many of the people and places in the story really existed. This account seems to corroborate that, as Negishi heard this tale directly from a person who had some close contact with the story (and is now a retainer, so clearly must be a reliable source!).

Incidentally, I climbed Mount Hikuma with my wife and Nagano-san a couple of years ago and, me being terribly out of shape and unathletic, I nearly passed out.

This is the stone that has been dubbed the legendary stone where Inō Budayū and his sumō wrestler friend went, although that’s entirely speculation.

The Yōkai of Hikuma Mountain, Geishū

Within Hikuma Mountain in Geishū lies an area that is forbidden to enter. There is a seven shaku tall stone pagoda inscribed with the elements of earth, water, fire, wind, and void, and legend says that a yōkai named Sanmoto Gorōzaemon lives there. However, there was a brave samurai named Inō Budayū. He and his close friend, a sumō wrestler, said:

“Why, in this day and age, should there be mysteries? Hey, let’s go to that cursed place on Hikuma Mountain and drink sake.”

So, they grabbed their bamboo flasks and went to the mountain, and they spent the entire day there drinking before heading home. About three days later, the sumō wrestler died for some unknown reason.

Starting the day after Budayū returned from Hikuma Mountain, strange things began happening every night at his place too, and continued for sixteen days. Even his servants asked for time off, and fled the house. Budayū wasn’t the least bit disturbed, and he remained dauntless. On the sixteenth day, the yōkai, perhaps having grown bored, introduced himself:

“Well now, brave man. I am Sanmoto Gorōzaemon.”

At that moment all of the strange phenomena ceased. Apparently the most difficult one to endure was when it smelled as if his rooms were scattered with manure. The filthy, foul stench was quite disturbing.

This was recounted by a man named Kobayashi Sensuke, who had lodged at Budayū’s place and is now a retainer of Lord Matsudaira of Buzen.

Today I’d like to share another story and painting from the upcoming Echizen-Wakasa Kidan. This story comes from a book called Echizen no kuni meiseki kō. Books like this were common in the Edo period, used as a kind of travel almanac that describes lands, people, and stories from various provinces. This sort of “travel story” was all the rage back then, and not only books but artworks were massed produced to satisfy the travel bug that people all over the country had. The famous ukiyoe landscapes by Hiroshige are another example of this, showcasing faraway lands and provinces that most people would not have the chance to visit. The prints were sold like “Wish You Were Here” postcards are sold today.

Anyway, this book is not a book of ghost stories, but a random hodgepodge of this and that, and this kidan is one that Nagano-san found in its pages. The translation below is straight from the original text, so it reads almost like a report of the legend. The author event notes that the dates in the story appear out of order, hinting that something fishy is going on here… (Note this is not the final text from the book, just a rough draft.)

The Giant Cat Disguised as a Wife
Inōe Tsubasaaki “Echizen no kuni kokon meiseki kō, Asuwa-gun”

The Horowa Daigongen monument (Shinmei Shrine, Hōei 4, Fukui City) located in front of the Hakusan shrine is colloquially known as “the cat’s grave.”

Inscription: “An auspicious day in March, Shōhō 2 (1645), erected by Kawasumi Kakuhira Okikatsu.”

During the Shōō era (1652-55), Kawasumi Okikatsu’s wife suddenly had a double. It was not possible to distinguish which one of them was the real wife and which one was a yōkai based on their usual behavior.

One evening, during a drinking party, several flies landed on one of the wives and, seeing her wiggle her ear in order to shoo the flies away, Okikatsu grabbed his bow from the adjacent room and shot her to death. A short time after, the wife transformed into a giant cat. This is recorded in a book called Eikyōroku.

Is is said that this cat was deified as Horowa Gongen; according to one theory, Horowa was the protector god of Kawasumi Okikatsu’s birthplace, and this monument was erected in thanks to the deity after he prayed to it for help in dispelling the yōkai.

Kawasumi Okikatsu was a landed samurai in Fukui Domain with an estate worth 200 koku. Since Shōhō took place before Shōō, the recording of Shōhō in Eikyōroku may be due to an error in transmission.

Interesting enough, this story is a familiar pattern found all over Japan. In fact, a few years ago I covered a similar story in Shokoku hyakumonogatari during A-Yokai-A-Day. Here’s that one for reference:

Sugiyama Hyōbu of Dewa Province’s Double Wife Disaster
Shokoku hyakumonogatari

There was a samurai from Dewa Province named Sugiyama Hyōbu. One night his wife went out the back door to use the outhouse, returned a little while later, and went to bed. A short while later there was a knock on the door.

“Who’s there?” asked Hyōbu.

His wife’s voice answered. Hyōbu was perplexed. He opened the door to let her in. Then he lit a lantern and inspected the two women closely. They were identical to each other in every way. He was even more perplexed.

When morning came, Hyōbu put both of his wives to work in different areas of the house. No matter how he tested them, there was no difference between them at all. He continued to scrutinize them, to no avail, when finally, someone told him:

“A henge will always have round hands, like paws.”

So Hyōbu inspected both of his wives’ hands. As it turned out, one of the wives’ hands were slightly round! Surely she was the henge. So Hyōbu immediately cut her head off.

Unfortunately, that one turned out to be his actual wife.

Therefore, the other wife must surely be the henge! Hyōbe went to cut off her head too. She tried everything to stop him, begging, lamenting, and cursing him, but he did not listen. He cut off her head.

But upon close inspection, this one turned out to be his actual wife.

Hyōbe was completely perplexed. He left the wives’ corpses out for a few days, but neither one changed at all.

Such strange things do happen, don’t they?

One more note — the Horowa Shrine still stands in Fukui today, a small addition build aside the much larger Shinmei Shrine. I’ve been there a few times, and it is absolutely dedicated to cats. There is a spot to leave donations of dried fish for the cat god, and there are cat charms and cat statues there.

There is one more cat story related to this shrine, so as a bonus, I’ll share it below. This one appeared not in an Edo period book, but in a Meiji era newspaper!

The Curse of the Calico Cat
Fukui Shinbun, Meiji 16, February 27
The following story doesn’t seem possible, but I am recording it just as I have heard it.

There is a calico cat kept at the home of Monzō, a resident of Tenga Village, Yoshida County, Fukui Prefecture (now Fukui City) who is very old and turned ninety-nine this year. Everyone in the house loves it, saying, “Mike, Mike,” and petting and rubbing it.

Recently, while Monzō was away and his son was watching the house, this Mike repeatedly suddenly changed form, turned to Monzō’s wife, told her, “Say nothing of this to anyone,” then put on a conical hat and performed various dances.

At first, Monzō’s wife kept this a deep secret and did not speak of it to anyone, but it was so incredible that she eventually told Monzō in secret. Monzō was so astonished that he said, “What kind of curse could fall upon us for owning such a cat?” He immediately left for Fukui City to make an offering at the Nekomata Shrine (Horowa Shrine) on the grounds of the Shinmei Shrine (Fukui City, Hōei). He prayed with his whole heart, “Please make it so that Mike does not come back to our house ever again,” This was on February 17.

It seems the Nekomata Shrine answered his prayer. When Monzō returned home, Mike was nowhere to be seen. While he was rejoicing that his wish had been granted, his wife suddenly looked unwell, and she stormed about the room as if she had gone mad, rambling on and on about incoherent things. Even today she still hasn’t gotten better. And so, the neighbors all say that she was cursed by the old cat, because she betrayed its request and told someone its secret.

Tonight’s story is another more narrative one like last night’s. And even better, it has two yokai for the price of one! You don’t often hear stories about yokai working together to get something done, but there are a few stories like that. In this one, we have a team of yūrei + kitsune.

I enjoy that Negishi seems to have taken the time to investigate this mystery while he was in Edo. His final paragraph puts the story into a contemporary context, and while it doesn’t add anything to the story itself, it does make it feel more in touch with the times.

The Ghost Who Asked a Fox to Stop a Drinking Problem

In Sakuma-chō, Kanda, there lived a man named Mankichi who loved sake and drank morning and night. One time, he called his daughter and said, “Prepare five gō (one gō is 180 ml) of sake for me to drink.”

Knowing his preferences, she took down the sake warmer and went to the sake shop next door and had them pour five gō of sake. Then she warmed it up and gave it to her father. Her father was pleased and tried to pour it into his bowl, but he found there was not a single drop inside.

He called his daughter and demanded, “What is this?”

His daughter was greatly surprised. “I carefully watched them pour the sake, so that cannot be possible,” she said.

She took the sake warmer, and this time had them pour one shō (1.8 liters) of sake. She brought it home and immediately warmed it up and served it. When her father poured it into his bowl, once again there was not a single drop inside, leaving him in a terrible mood.

The daughter was astonished and said, “The other day mother appeared to me in a dream and said that your heavy drinking was bad for your health and bad for the family. She told me to watch carefully and get you to stop drinking. I tried to get you to stop, but you wouldn’t listen, so I didn’t press any further. Could this be why the sake disappeared?”

The father replied, “I also had such a dream, but I dismissed it as nonsense. However, if that is the case, I shall stop drinking.”

And so, for a time afterward, he did stop. Then, the sake flasks and jugs that had recently vanished reappeared. However, at a neighborhood meeting he once again broke his vow and drank. Once again, all of his sake utensils vanished, and his daughter began to act as if she was possessed and blurted out:

“The spirit of my late mother, grieved by your excessive drinking, asked a fox to help reprimand you. Since you broke your promise, I have decided to return and be your chaperone.”

The father was terrified, and he vowed, “I swear firmly that from this day forward I will abstain from alcohol!”

After that, the daughter quickly recovered from her madness.

According to rumor, at Heisaburō’s store in Asakusa Mototorigoe-chō, there is a fifty-three year old man named Mankichi. His current wife, Sugi, is forty; his son, Ichitarō, is twenty-five; and his daughter, Gin, is eighteen. It is said that his late wife, Ei, who died sixteen years ago, was always worried about Mankichi’s heavy drinking, and was always admonishing him. Gin became mentally ill around the end of this January, and as she rambled about various things, it became clear that Ei had possessed her. As a ghost, Ei couldn’t do anything herself, so people say she asked a fox to use its magical powers to admonish Mankichi. Although it’s a strange story, it has become the talk of the town, so I am recording it. While the kindness of the late wife was only natural, people laugh at how the fox she enlisted was also a kind one.

Although Negishi was stationed on Sadō Island and in Edo for most of the time he wrote Mimibukuro, his stories were collected from people who traveled all around Japan. Some of them were probably traders on kitamaebune who brought stories from all over the place. Tonight’s story is one from my hometown of Fukui, and the Asuwa River mentioned is very close to my home and one of my favorite walking paths. This story is not in Echizen-Wakasa Kidan, despite being from here; however it will probably make it into a future volume.

This story is also interesting because it is much more narrative and story-like than many of the others we have seen. This was clearly a fantastic legend that was told to Negishi, rather than a report of a strange incident, and his writing shows it.

The poem in the story took me several hours to translate. If you remember last year’s A-Yokai-A-Day I probably complained a lot about translating Japanese poetry. It’s so hard to do, without utterly destroying the meaning and the beauty of the poem. That is once again the case here, as the painfully short line —

暮每にとひ來しものをあすは川あすの夜波のあだに寄覽

— evokes so much imagery and symbolism, while leaving so much unsaid. Japanese and English are extremely different in this way. English is more strict about context and grammar than Japanese in a lot of ways, and that is especially clear in poetry. In Japanese you can drop off any part of the sentence that you don’t want or need, and the reader has to infer that part. That makes it possible to create short and simple poems with evocative language and a specific meter that still carry double or triple meanings. These kind of poems are used as battles of wits or challenges very often in stories.

There are two parts of this story that leave me unsatisfied. The first is that we never get to hear the lord’s reply poem! Since it caused the turtle to stop attacking, we have to assume it was a brilliant poem that both demonstrated that the lord understood the double/hidden meanings of the original poem, and that solved the problem in one way or the other and satisfied the turtle. What could it have been???

The second is that Genzō gets a pardon for his crime, and it is written off as not a malicious act. This of course is because the man he killed was not a samurai, and thus was not important enough to warrant a punishment for his murder. Yuck. But that’s how life was under the samurai…

The Strange Turtle in Asuwa River

In Echizen, in Fukui Domain, there lived a brave and bold man named something-or-other Genzō. Yet, it was precisely because of his bold nature that he was ordered to serve as a retainer and sent to Fukui.

In Fukui flows the Asuwa River. It is traversed by a large bridge called Tsukumobashi. A giant turtle lives in that river and it is said to sometimes snatch people.

Now, one day, when Genzō was crossing Tsukumobashi, he saw a truly extraordinary giant turtle on the riverbank. Genzō thought, “That must be the abominable man-eating turtle!” And he drew his sword, stripped naked, and dove into the river.

He easily slew the turtle, and he asked the nearby villagers to help pull it out of the water. “The shell I shall present to the lord, while the meat I shall take home and eat with sake,” he decided.

He ordered his attendant to prepare the turtle while he took a nap. His attendant thought deeply, “A turtle this large must be poisonous. It would be unwise to let my master eat it. I shall dispose of it in the river, and explain my reasons.” He immediately discarded the turtle and then told his master. Genzō flew into a rage and mercilessly cut the attendant down.

The lord declared that Genzō’s handling of the matter was inexcusable. Genzō was placed under arrest and confined to a single room. Though he was such a brave man, Genzō was afraid of the lord’s punishment and his spirit weakened. Late at night when he was lying in bed, someone came to him and recited a poem:

Every evening my lover came to me at Asuwa River, yet tomorrow night only the empty waves will wash ashore. Now my revenge will come every night.

Then he struck Genzō on the head. The pain was unbearable, so he got up, but nobody was there anymore. This happened two nights in a row, so Genzō prepared himself, and around the time the poem was recited, he lifted his head from the pillow and held the pillow out. The pillow was shredded into bits. Though he was greatly startled, word of this reached the lord.

The lord said, “What a strange thing. Genzō killed a male turtle, so perhaps this is a female turtle seeking revenge.”

Then he composed a reply poem, sealed it, and floated it down the Asuwa River. After that the vengeful spirit ceased its attack on Genzō.

From that day on, Genzō reformed his ways and became more earnest.

Declaring that it was not a crime of malice, the lord forgave Genzō’s offense, and Genzō safely returned to duty.

Tonight’s story is another pet story (don’t worry — I promise the rest of the stories this month are not all animal ones, although I do have a couple more animal stories to share that I like). But this one won’t make anyone shed tears (I hope) like the previous horse, cat, and rat stories. In fact, I hope this one gets you to laugh, just as I laughed out loud the first time I read it.

I’m not a cat person, but this story still ranks very high on my list of favorite Mimibukuro stories. Enjoy!

The Strange Cat

There was a certain samurai family living near Banchō who never kept any cats. When somebody asked the master of the house why this was, he told them the following:

“There is a reason for it, but it would not do if it were widely known, and so I don’t talk about it. Yet, since you ask me so persistently, I shall tell you.

“Back in my grandfather’s time, we had a cat that we kept for many years. One day, this cat pounced at two or three sparrows perched on the edge of the veranda. The sparrows flew away immediately, but the cat uttered in a child’s voice, ‘Darn it!’

“Startled, my grandfather jumped on the cat and pinned it down. He grabbed a fire poker and raised it up, then snarled with murderous rage: ‘You are a mere beast, yet you speak! How unnatural!’

“The cat replied, ‘But I never spoke a word until now!’

“My grandfather was so startled that his grip loosened, and the cat leapt away and was never seen again. This incident is the reason.”

From that day onward, it was decreed in this household that nobody would ever own a cat, and to this day they strictly adhere to the ban and do not keep cats.